HARARE — The National Prosecuting Authority has declined to prosecute preacher Apostle Batsirai Java over a leaked telephone conversation, halting the case before it reached a magistrate and marking a sharp turn in a police investigation that had brought him into custody.
Java, 43, spent less than an hour at the prosecutor’s office at Harare Magistrates Court on Friday before the NPA ruled that the charge brought by police was incompetent and would not be taken forward. He had been arrested two days earlier by detectives from the Criminal Investigation Department’s Law and Order section in Harare.
The charge was publishing or communicating a false statement prejudicial to the State, under section 31(b)(i)(C) of the Criminal Law (Codification and Reform) Act. It arose from a telephone conversation with journalist Everson Mushava that police said was recorded between May 25 and May 28 and later circulated on social media.
The decision means Java will not face prosecution on the charge presented to the NPA. The case was stopped before he appeared before a magistrate, bringing the immediate prosecution effort to an end.
The NPA’s decision came days after Prosecutor-General Justice Loice Matanda-Moyo, the widow of the late former military boss and Foreign Affairs Minister Sibusiso ‘SB’ Moyo, urged prosecutors to return poorly investigated case files to police for further work. Speaking at the Authority’s strategy review workshop in Mutare on November 10, she said prosecutors should scrutinise dockets carefully and take only fully prepared, evidence-backed cases to court.
Matanda-Moyo said prosecutors should not hesitate to send files back with clear instructions about evidence still needed before a case was brought before the courts. “Where we take ill-investigated dockets into court, we are doing a disservice to our clients. We must not shy away from sending dockets back to the police with clear instructions on the evidence that still needs to be gathered before the matter is brought before the courts,” she said.
She also urged prosecutors not to rush cases to court, saying the focus should be on quality investigations and ensuring justice. Her remarks set out the NPA’s general approach to reviewing police files. The Authority did not publicly say the instruction was specifically connected to Java’s case.
Police had accused Java and Mushava of making false claims about businessman Kudakwashe Tagwirei’s influence over government. According to the police remand request, the conversation suggested Tagwirei had become a political kingmaker with the power to shape government decisions and influence which ministers President Emmerson Mnangagwa could appoint or remove.
The allegations went further. Police said the conversation claimed that government business was being conducted at Tagwirei’s residence, where ministers, senior police and army officers, Central Intelligence Organisation directors, army generals and senior judges were allegedly summoned to receive instructions.
Investigators alleged that the statements were published despite being known to be false, and that their publication was intended to undermine public confidence in law enforcement agencies, the prison service and the Defence Forces of Zimbabwe. Those claims formed the basis of the charge put before prosecutors.
The police case followed months of controversy around the recording, which spread across social media platforms in May. The audio was described as a conversation involving Java and Mushava. Its contents focused on Tagwirei’s alleged political influence and the balance of power in government, claims that quickly drew attention because they involved senior state institutions and the country’s leadership.
The police action against Java had previously been described publicly as a treason investigation. But when detectives arrested him on November 12, the charge brought to prosecutors was not treason. It concerned the alleged communication of a false statement prejudicial to the State. The difference between the earlier public description and the charge ultimately put forward added a new turn to the case.
Before the arrest, police officers had reportedly searched for Java at his home and church. Former opposition legislator Job Sikhala said Java handed himself in after a series of searches linked to the recording. Earlier visits were reported at Tabernacle of Grace premises in Harare, Ruwa and Tynwald, as investigators sought to find the preacher.
A reported visit to the church’s Harare offices in June involved officers asking to see Java. Church officials said the officers told them they had been sent to locate him. The search activity continued to attract attention as the audio circulated, and the police investigation shifted from reported efforts to find him to his arrest and presentation to prosecutors.
Java has denied that he was the speaker in the recording. In a previous statement, he said: “I am not the person in that audio, this is my voice, this is me speaking and I am not even in communication with the person who is at the end of that audio.”
The recording also drew responses from Java’s younger brother, Prophet Passion Java, who publicly distanced himself from the claims in the audio. The brothers have been associated with different political positions. Apostle Java is the widower of Vimbai Tsvangirai-Java, daughter of the late opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai, while Passion Java has publicly supported Mnangagwa and the ruling ZANU PF party.
That family connection has added public interest to the case, but the immediate issue was the charge police presented to the NPA. Prosecutors declined to take it forward, and Java was not brought before a magistrate on the case.
The recording’s allegations touched on claims of influence over government appointments and decisions, and on the role of state institutions. Police said the comments could damage confidence in those institutions. The NPA’s decision focused on the charge itself: prosecutors ruled it incompetent and declined to prosecute.
The outcome is a setback for the police investigation after months of inquiries, reported searches and the arrest. For Java, the immediate threat of prosecution on this charge has ended before a court hearing could begin. The NPA’s decision leaves the case at a standstill, while Matanda-Moyo’s recent remarks underline the Authority’s stated expectation that case files should be thoroughly reviewed and supported by evidence before they proceed to court.










